Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Aja's avatar

Great summary on the systemic failures of medicine. As a trained general and vascular surgeon in the 1980s, I always felt the regimented process was to create self discipline and introspection in one’s avocation. I was taught and trained that there is many ways to “skin a cat” as long as a satisfying outcome resulted for the patient. There was mostly critical thinking involved in the lengthy , rigorous education between residents and staff. However , there were a few staff professors who took the “my way or the highway” approach. Unfortunately, that approach has become the rule not the exception as Big Pharma and Big Medical Device Technology drives the financial incentives in every hospital and academic training program. Along with this outcome is the perverse federal government incentives from HHS with DEI and woke thought resulting in a Pavlovian response from medical professors, students, hospital administrators, and clinical researchers. I don’t recognize my field of vascular surgery. The specialty journals are filled with nothing but feel good, DEI garbage editorials along with full page ads from the latest medical device technology. And eight years post retirement, I chuckle that the latest clinical studies , laced with poor statistical analysis, are vascular surgical issues debated back to the beginning of the millennium. While the progress in device technology is truly mind boggling , 80% don’t improve long term outcomes mortality or the ever important quality of life. Depending on one’s specialty what is axiomatic these days 1)” if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail” 2) “it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his income depended on his not understanding it” - Upton Sinclair.

Expand full comment
A Midwestern Doctor's avatar

After I posted this article, I realized I forgot one of the most classic examples of financial incentives in medicine. Doctors who vaccinate are both paid to vaccinate, and given a significant bonus based off the percentage of people they vaccinate. Because of both, especially the latter, many are highly incentivized to ensure all the patients in their practice vaccinate.

Expand full comment
160 more comments...

No posts